3344 RICHMOND TERRACE: 1940 ↑ TODAY ↓
On Friday, February 15th, 1946, the twin daughters of Captain De Hart, considered one of the founders of Mariner's Harbor, were murdered by a distant relative who, according to the NY Times, had spent time in mental hospital. May and Viola De Hart had lived in the house their entire lives and taken over their family businesses and properties when their bachelor brother, Mathias, retired in 1901. They had sold a large portion of their landholdings to the railroad, but at the time of their murder still owned 42 acres, stretching from the water's edge, southward to the railroad tracks. North of the Terrace on the picture below, you can see M. De Hart Ex.
The 81-year-old sisters lived alone in a once attractive house that had become weathered and worn without gas or electricity. The picture of the women's lives as painted in the SI Advance's description of their home is a sad one.
 |
SI ADVANCE Feb 18th, 1946 |
 |
| Gordon De Hart |
Their killer was a distant relative, 34-year-old Gordon De Hart, who live a few blocks away in a house that's still there on Richmond Terrace. As described by Walter Dugan, a friend of his who was with him when he bludgeoned the sisters to death, said the two had been drinking and walking along the Terrace when they spotted May De Hart in her yard. When she refused to speak with him, Gordon, accompanied by Dugan, followed her into the house. When she then refused to give him some money, of which he was convinced she had plenty, Gordon picked up the wedge from the woodpile and beat her on the head. When Viola attempted to protect May, he did the same to her.
In Dugan's telling, it's a fairly straightforward thing. According to the corner's description it seems much more brutal. May's ear had been cut "as cleanly" as by a knife, and both their skulls were fractured. Viola's body lay across May's. Both women still held hair pulled from their attacker's scalp in their hands.
They were discovered by a girl who lived down the block. The Advance articles say she had come to warn them about a brushfire on the back of their property. The NY Times, on the other hand, describes a curious 11-year-old who found the bodies by being nosy.
In their words, Dolores Schoppman, after watching the brushfire for a while noticed that part of the De Hart's backdoor had been kicked in. Her interest piqued, she looked through the kitchen window and saw the bloodied bodies on the floor. That strikes me as believable as the Advance's story.
By all the accounts in both papers, the De Hart sisters were courteous, but not communicative. In the mid-thirties, they donated the equivalent of about $70,000 to the Mariner's Harbor Reformed Church (now the Fellowship Baptist Church). When the Rev. Owens attempted to thank them for their generosity, they wouldn't come to the door.
They were perceived as being rich and it was believed they kept large amounts of money in their house. That was enough, apparently, to send Gordon De Hart into the rage that left them dead.
Their house was later emptied of all its contents which were then disposed of by their lawyer at the directions of the sisters' heirs. Among the items removed was a chair from the 1780s as well as other furniture from the mid-19th century. By 1977, the house was abandoned and caught fire. I'm not sure when it was torn down, but the townhouses on its location are listed as being built in 1988.
I came to this story by a tortuous road. Looking up information about a house in St George, I came across the name of Dr. Samuel Reback. Then, deciding to see if there was anything interesting about him, I came across this SI Advance article from June of 1946 describing Dr. Reback's testimony on behalf of the prosecution in Gordon De Hart's trial. The description of the crime was more than enough to send me backwards to event itself.
Today, I discovered that Dr. Reback was a highly respected Park Avenue doctor who lived until 102, only dying in 2002.
No comments:
Post a Comment